LGPedia:UGC desk/evaluations/Tannhaus/initial

From LGPedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Series: Tannhaus
Current Tier: Tentative 2
Date: Added March 25th, 2008, effective as of April 25th, 2008
Posted by user: ~ Renegade (talk | contribs)
Reason for re-evaluation: This series was subject to the Revamp discussion, and, although tagged, overlooked. It has been added as Tentative Tier 2 to the list, like a new series, and given that it didn't have a chance to be discussed in the revamp before, we'll assume the one month grace period is in effect.

Due to the special nature of this evaluation (post-revamp revamp discussion), opinions can be added immediately, but any decision will not become effective before April 25th, 2008 due to the grace period. (The two week timeout rule does not apply in this case, logically.)

As for my own, personal opinion, on one hand, the series looks rather small and barely noticed, but on the other hand, it seems to have a high count of episodes, and, and that is the important factor, in my opinion, it is the only factual UGC series there is. At least as far as I know, this is the only series that is not "fan fiction" or a spin-off, but actually discusses the "factual" data given by LG15. This, in my opinion, is notable, and, as such, I vote for keeping it on LGPedia as a Tier 2 series.
As a small reminder, we have a previous precedent for this kind of listing: The Deacons (commenter) will stay after the Revamp due to the fact that it is the only comments-based UGC known (and thus notable).

I think I agree with the Tier 2 evaluation, but the page needs a LOT more added. If it can't get that, I'd go with a Tier 1. - Shiori 15:45, 25 March 2008 (CDT)

I also agree with a Tier 2 evaluation. Tannhaus was also the person most responsible for getting the overt Thelema imagery and plot direction removed from lonelygirl15 and the website. --Milowent 16:10, 25 March 2008 (CDT)

Hello guys. It's probably been a year since I've been here. I just dropped in to see what has changed and to make sure the URL changed pointing to me. I'm not sure about all this Tier stuff, but if anyone needs any information for this article, I'll answer any questions you might have. Just send an email to tannhaus@moderngnosis.org. I just tried to help you guys out by redesigning the article a bit. By all means, though, it is your article and you can change it/delete it as you wish. --Tannhaus 14:01, 15 April 2008 (CDT)

Given that there was a consensus on the page, and the fanfic revamp is dead, Tannhaus stays Tier 2.

Retrieved from "http://lg15.com/lgpedia/index.php?title=LGPedia:UGC_desk/evaluations/Tannhaus/initial&oldid=140533"