Talk:I Miss Her

Someone please explain this to me. In this email, which is the same email Bree references in the voicemail in episode 12 of 12in12, she says she has p.monkey with her. But how did TAAG get it back? Emma had it in Decision Time (Sept. 14, 2007). Are we to assume Bree really did not have P. Monkey with her and just claimed she did in the email? Why oh why does this bother me! --Milowent 13:38, 9 April 2008 (CDT)

Um... Where does she say she has P. Monkey? She says that they tried to replace him, but that she'd never want another backup singer than P. Monkey. That doesn't really scream "he's with me"... - Shiori 13:55, 9 April 2008 (CDT)

i think its at least ambiguous. statements like "it's that I only wish they treat P. Monkey with the same kindness" "They tried to replace him -- can you believe that?" make me logically think p.monkey was with her. but i think your explanation is what we have to go with. that and the fact that the writers never thought about this issue (in bree's gone the writers forgot that bree's couldn't drive, for example, that was later admitted by glenn). with all the times bree was kidnapped and rescued, its hard to believe p monkey looks so good. --Milowent 15:46, 9 April 2008 (CDT)