Talk:She's Missing

Psmith 06:33, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

Picture Debate: Escape vs. Romance

Why did you change the Pic? The one I put up first, I thought captured the essence of the video. But you decided to put a "romantic " picture there that totally creates a false image of Bree's and Jonas's relationship. I know there are at least 100 girls out there that want to believe that Jonas and Bree are in love, but that's just not where the story is at. If I hadn't already seen the video, I would assume from that picture that Bree and Jonas were about to jump into bed together. -misty 00:46, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

I think there is a definitely love connection going on. And I don't just say that because I have a $50 bet with ApotheosisAZ about it. I can't say one pic is preferred over the other as the video had two storylines. --Milowent 00:49, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

You know what, I think two people can watch the same thing and get totally different ideas about what it's about. To me the main point of the vid was advancing the Bree and Jonas relationship. But if other people thought it was more about Jonas and Daniel looking for Jules, I'm fine with that too. I know that's what the video was actually /about/ but I just felt like the BJ stuff was more the character-purpose of the vid. I'd love opinions though? :) --Zoey 00:58, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

Hmm, this one is a little tough. I think that we see the plot moving along more often than we see a "romantic connection", so maybe we should highlight the romantic stuff when it does come along. That's not to say the plot stuff isn't important--it definitely is--but the image obviously isn't the only thing that gives people information about the video. That's just my opinion, and there really isn't a right answer; it's just preference really.--Jonpro 01:12, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

Except in this video there wasn't any romantic stuff to highlight. The interaction in the scene that the picture came from was one of bree being upset and Jonas trying to comfort her. That picture out of context, you can't tell that breee had tears in her eyes and was upset. It looks like Bree and Jonas are looking at each other with passsionate desire, but if you look at it in context, you don't get that at all. The picture and the caption are telling a totally different story about Bree and Jonas's relationship than the video is. -misty 02:02, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

misty, you are in denial. jules missing is the initial cause for blog but as soon as jonas turns around to comfort bre, the plot focus shifts. the search for bre is a device, in this case, to illustrate a crucial character difference between jonas and daniel. daniel tends towards the direct aproach to solving the surface issues (jules is missing) and jonas tends towards the oblique aproach to the underlining issue (bre unable to shift jules' free will). the romantic implications are strong because ultamately, bre will fall in love with either or both jonas and daniel. granted she's in a stressful spot and doesn't have time for love right now but i'm sure anybody out there who has ever been in a stressful situation knows that these kinds of situations generaly open doors to romance. - platypus may 10 2007

I really think the current picture is perfect, this coming from someone who is semi-against Jonas and Bree becoming a "thing." The vid started out about Jules but ultimately became about Bree's distress over Jules, and Jonas comforting her. People will take from it what they want. This vid will soon be drowned in a couple days, so it's really not that big of a deal. Plus, people are blowing it up like Jonas and Bree started making out or something. He kissed her on the forehead, big deal. Yeah, it does seem like they are growing on eachother, but it seriously is not that major. Chelseyrl 12:21, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

I also agree that the BJ picture should stay and for many of the above reasons. I doubt Bree and Jonas will "make out all the time" as Sarah once claimed, but this is definitely a nod that something is brewing. And like Chelseyrl said, once we have a few more vids, we can see how all this will turn out. -- Phoenician 12:44 PM, 10 May 2007 (AZT)

Well if you want all want a pic of Bree and Jonas, how about . That's a much more honest pic for this Video -misty 15:36, 10 May 2007 (CDT)

you're being rediculous, misty. i can appreciate the analytical discussion but it's time to move on. platypus may 10 2007

I think I would have picked a similar or even exact frame to Zoey for the main video image had I not seen it already. (Sorry, Misty... 1 more vote for the current pic.) Bree gives Jonas a number of these wonderful looks during the video (e.g.

Ummm this video got taken down from youtube... weird..--67.10.187.154 20:39, 26 June 2008 (CDT)