Revision as of 05:34, 24 April 2007

Deletion

I disagree with the deletion nom for this page. The simple reason is that the List of New Girl candidates is just that, a list. It can't hold all the information pertaining to them. If someone wants to elaborate more on any girl (e.g., summarize their videos, write about their personality or interests, etc.), they can start an article on them, and the List page can link to the article. In the past we've usually been pretty considerate about allowing pages for spinoffs, this is no different.
Additionally, many viewers share the sentiment that soccerstar is another production by MM&G. This page should perhaps elaborate on the attributes of this spinoff that tipped off viewers.
OwenIsCool 10:31, 23 April 2007 (CDT)

I agree with OwensCool. Also, I made the page.

I would lean against deletion. Soccerstar and Jules are the 2 most likely to be canon. --Milowent 22:22, 23 April 2007 (CDT)

i think we should keep it. if it was just "she's a possible new girl" i'd delete it, but there's relevant and useful info here.

Excuse me?

Does Callmejules24 not have her own page? I believe she is on the list, no? If this page gets deleted, then Jule's page better get deleted.