Talk:Who would live in a room like this?

From LGPedia
Jump to: navigation, search

we don't know that gemma was working for the order the whole time she was making videos though. right? one logical theory is that she was co-opted after she started making videos (as the 1st few seemed to caution bree about the order). --Milowent 00:59, 17 August 2007 (CDT)

do you watch NBR? she did a video about Gemma. there's a link to it in the article. -- PrettySMRT
My thing with that side note is that its essenially contradicting commentary. The first note is fine because its analyzing the video. (Charlie's messy ways remind veiwers of Gemma's criticisms about her roomate) And while the second note is a factual and decent analysis of that first note, it's simply not relevant to the actual article. Again, overall the second note is decent, but I don't see its relevance to the article . . . only to the note. However, I don't want to start a revert war, so I'll still leave it as is (you did reword it afterall)
That said, Gemma may never have had a roomate, but then again, maybe she did - we saw her and Lucy walk out the same building, did she roomate with Lucy perhaps? Again, there's tons of possibilities. :) --Pheon 00:03, 21 August 2007 (CDT)
Well, since the second note is factual, the first seems a bit irrelevant in that it doesn't have much to do with possible plots in the future. I put the note up basically because I felt bad deleting it, like your mention of a revert war. I'll stay away from the article, but I think we should just leave all of it, add a 3rd sidenote, or delete it all. --PrettySMRT