Difference between revisions of "Talk:No Way To Live"
From LGPedia
Modelmotion (Talk | contribs) |
m |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
That's quite a huge spoiler... How about leaving the spoiler in the notes, and naming the hooded figure "Hooded figure" ? I'm saying this because the transcript is helping me to understand what my ears can't catch, being a non-native english speaker, and this totally spoiled me... for no reason. In fact, a "spoiler" wikicode should be created, hiding the spoilers unless you click on it... Well, the problem remains : how about leaving the spoilers in the Notes, and using the transcript as a "transcript" of what is seen, heard and shown, and not what is revealed in future videos ? -- [[User:MrTriangleRenversé|MrTriangleRenversé]] 13:06, 19 August 2008 (CDT) | That's quite a huge spoiler... How about leaving the spoiler in the notes, and naming the hooded figure "Hooded figure" ? I'm saying this because the transcript is helping me to understand what my ears can't catch, being a non-native english speaker, and this totally spoiled me... for no reason. In fact, a "spoiler" wikicode should be created, hiding the spoilers unless you click on it... Well, the problem remains : how about leaving the spoilers in the Notes, and using the transcript as a "transcript" of what is seen, heard and shown, and not what is revealed in future videos ? -- [[User:MrTriangleRenversé|MrTriangleRenversé]] 13:06, 19 August 2008 (CDT) | ||
: Interesting point. I am not sure the question of spoilers has ever come up on the pedia before. Definttely food for thought. It should just say Hooded figure with a link to the Notes section that contains the reveal--[[User:Modelmotion|modelmotion]] 17:26, 19 August 2008 (CDT) | : Interesting point. I am not sure the question of spoilers has ever come up on the pedia before. Definttely food for thought. It should just say Hooded figure with a link to the Notes section that contains the reveal--[[User:Modelmotion|modelmotion]] 17:26, 19 August 2008 (CDT) | ||
| + | :: The issue has come up before, as the main page of the pedia says: "All pages on this encyclopedia are written from an all-knowing point of view. If you have not seen all episodes of a series yet, and don't want to see SPOILERS, do not read further." I don't particularly love that rule, but am not sure we can bury all spoilers. In this case though, I would be ok with the proposed change. The notes are usually a source of major spoilers. --[[User:Milowent|Milowent]] 21:27, 19 August 2008 (CDT) | ||
| + | ::: Ok, I've edited it, since I found that, in [[In the Closet]], where the hooded figure appears again, is doesn't spoil in the transcript and uses "Hooded Figure" instead of "Sarah ...". But, the idea of a "hidden spoiler template" may be discussed... I'll do that in [[LGPedia:Lucy's_Balcony]]... | ||
Latest revision as of 11:09, 20 August 2008
"Sarah (as hooded figure):" ?!?
That's quite a huge spoiler... How about leaving the spoiler in the notes, and naming the hooded figure "Hooded figure" ? I'm saying this because the transcript is helping me to understand what my ears can't catch, being a non-native english speaker, and this totally spoiled me... for no reason. In fact, a "spoiler" wikicode should be created, hiding the spoilers unless you click on it... Well, the problem remains : how about leaving the spoilers in the Notes, and using the transcript as a "transcript" of what is seen, heard and shown, and not what is revealed in future videos ? -- MrTriangleRenversé 13:06, 19 August 2008 (CDT)
- Interesting point. I am not sure the question of spoilers has ever come up on the pedia before. Definttely food for thought. It should just say Hooded figure with a link to the Notes section that contains the reveal--modelmotion 17:26, 19 August 2008 (CDT)
- The issue has come up before, as the main page of the pedia says: "All pages on this encyclopedia are written from an all-knowing point of view. If you have not seen all episodes of a series yet, and don't want to see SPOILERS, do not read further." I don't particularly love that rule, but am not sure we can bury all spoilers. In this case though, I would be ok with the proposed change. The notes are usually a source of major spoilers. --Milowent 21:27, 19 August 2008 (CDT)
- Ok, I've edited it, since I found that, in In the Closet, where the hooded figure appears again, is doesn't spoil in the transcript and uses "Hooded Figure" instead of "Sarah ...". But, the idea of a "hidden spoiler template" may be discussed... I'll do that in LGPedia:Lucy's_Balcony...
- The issue has come up before, as the main page of the pedia says: "All pages on this encyclopedia are written from an all-knowing point of view. If you have not seen all episodes of a series yet, and don't want to see SPOILERS, do not read further." I don't particularly love that rule, but am not sure we can bury all spoilers. In this case though, I would be ok with the proposed change. The notes are usually a source of major spoilers. --Milowent 21:27, 19 August 2008 (CDT)
