Difference between revisions of "Talk:Best moments of 2006"
(question about criteria/usefulness) |
|||
| Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
As a regular on the forum, I am kind of confused by this page. Did I miss the place where people chose these categories/entries or are they simply one group's decision? What is the basis for "a best fan contribution?" Humor, wiki-work, moderating? This is confusing to me. It seems like a lot of fun for those who know the people on the list or did the choosing. I only know of Holly, however. Are these chatroom folks? If so, perhaps this would be best suited with a disclaimer. Otherwise it is quite alienating to those who have no idea who the people on the list are or the criteria for episodes and things being on the list. I don't mean to be Captain Buzz-Killer or Professor Whiney, but it does seems cliquish. Just my opinion, though... [[User:Ogog|Ogog]] 13:20, 31 December 2006 (CST) | As a regular on the forum, I am kind of confused by this page. Did I miss the place where people chose these categories/entries or are they simply one group's decision? What is the basis for "a best fan contribution?" Humor, wiki-work, moderating? This is confusing to me. It seems like a lot of fun for those who know the people on the list or did the choosing. I only know of Holly, however. Are these chatroom folks? If so, perhaps this would be best suited with a disclaimer. Otherwise it is quite alienating to those who have no idea who the people on the list are or the criteria for episodes and things being on the list. I don't mean to be Captain Buzz-Killer or Professor Whiney, but it does seems cliquish. Just my opinion, though... [[User:Ogog|Ogog]] 13:20, 31 December 2006 (CST) | ||
| + | |||
| + | :That's why I edited it out. Didn't want to delete it completely without the people who created it having a chance to have a say in it, though. Btw it's comment board people and I have no idea what the basis for the list was. [[User:Dream|Dream]] 21:30, 31 December 2006 (CST) | ||
Revision as of 03:30, 1 January 2007
Best Fan Contributions:
Lizard
Sydney
HoorayforMeI'mMakingOut
Joe X
Gypsy
Naxan
ByGollyIt'sHolly
Marbella
Edited the list out because I'm not sure about itsinformational or entertaining value, but if you want itin again, please feel free to put it in again. I just stuck to Treefunk's advice that LGPedia is not so much about giving credit to individual users. All regulars know and praise the "comment board elite" anyway and the newbies won't get much information out of the list.
Dream 04:15, 31 December 2006 (CST)
This is the link to the second Top15 list page. We should try to incorporate it here to avoid confusion.
Dream 04:31, 31 December 2006 (CST)
As a regular on the forum, I am kind of confused by this page. Did I miss the place where people chose these categories/entries or are they simply one group's decision? What is the basis for "a best fan contribution?" Humor, wiki-work, moderating? This is confusing to me. It seems like a lot of fun for those who know the people on the list or did the choosing. I only know of Holly, however. Are these chatroom folks? If so, perhaps this would be best suited with a disclaimer. Otherwise it is quite alienating to those who have no idea who the people on the list are or the criteria for episodes and things being on the list. I don't mean to be Captain Buzz-Killer or Professor Whiney, but it does seems cliquish. Just my opinion, though... Ogog 13:20, 31 December 2006 (CST)
- That's why I edited it out. Didn't want to delete it completely without the people who created it having a chance to have a say in it, though. Btw it's comment board people and I have no idea what the basis for the list was. Dream 21:30, 31 December 2006 (CST)
