LGPedia:Lucy's Balcony/Fanfic revamp
Note: Several resolved and abandoned discussions have been archived in order to keep the page tidy.
Contents
Glossary
| Tier 1 | Tier 1 Fanfic is not notable enough to get listed on LGPedia. All vlogs not belonging to a series fall under this category. (Singular notable vlogs may be listed on a single listing page in the future.) |
|---|---|
| Tier 2 | Tier 2 Fanfic gets a single page with a few basic facts like creators, general plot/topic outline and maybe a list of characters. |
| Tier 3 | Tier 3 Fanfic gets a comprehensive single page, including a more detailed plot outline, episode lists, and similar additional information. |
| Tier 4 | Tier 4 Fanfic is fanfic that, under all objective considerations, should belong to Tier 3, but for some subjective or organizational reason are allowed to branch out and create more than one page. (An example would be that a series is rather small in notability, but has a high number of episodes, so that a separate list of videos makes more sense.) |
| Tier 5 | Tier 5 Fanfic are all "big" series, like OpAphid, Maddison Atkins or Redearth88. They get the same array of pages as canon series, including templates, character/actor pages and categories. |
Criteria
The important and sole decisive criterion is notability. Is a series notable enough to be listed at all, and, if yes, how notable is it?
Unfortunately, notability is very subjective. As such, we have to fall back on objective data to decide whether a series is notable. Such objective data can be:
- Did the series become canon at one point in its life? (Example: OpAphid)
- Did the series get a shoutout or referred to in a canon episode? (Example: Paulmark18)
- How many people in the community have seen the series? (Example: Maddison Atkins)
- How many people in the community have heard of the series? (Example: Immant, Cassieiswatching)
- How many views do the videos of the series have on average?
- How many episodes does the series have?
- How many main characters are there? (Just one vlogger, or an entire cast?)
- How big/complex is the production? (Just one vlogger with a webcam, or an entire crew with multiple sets and scripted episodes?)
- And, especially for Tier 4 series, is there anything special or exceptional that needs to be considered? (Example: Lonelygirl362436 - technically a rather small series, but highly notable because it was produced by the Creators, had Daniel in it and a well-known hollywood actress as its lead.)
- [Please expand this list]
List of fan series currently archived on the pedia
If somebody feels like making an actual list, be my guest. In the meantime, there's an older list here, and the general fanfic category.
- LonesomeOctober -- Right now, I would say this needs to be a Tier 4 -- ten videos, and they have a notoreity in the Breeniverse (perhaps because of the "WANKER?!!!" arc). --Pheon 17:18, 27 January 2008 (CST)
- ZorinXL, Will-O-Wisp, and Worldfiles should either be in Tier 1 or on the Tier JonPro was suggesting (see below) - I'm guessing they're fanfic, but then again, I've never heard of them, and yet they all have wonderful pages devoted to them (there all actually a dead-end pages (they don't link to anything else on the Pedia and redirects its list of videos to YouTube) --Pheon 03:19, 27 January 2008 (CST)
Agreed listings
Tier 1
- fourthface - doesn't seem very popular; not very many views.
Tier 2
- Bubbleteagirl - a lot of videos, a few of which have 10,000+ views, but no connection to the Creators.
- Frankiswaking - some notability, 250+ subscribers; should probably be combined with Frankiswaiting@gmail.com (even though they're different, they're still related); maybe should be Tier 3?
Tier 3
Tier 4
- lonelygirl362436 -- as said above, though only three-episode series, the Creators played a part in it, Daniel had a role, and it was viral marketing for Epic Movie
Tier 5
- Redearth88, OpAphid, & Maddison Atkins -- Not only do their stories merge into a larger story, but one of Redearth' puppetmasters is Glenn Rubenstein (who was creator of OpAphid), ans he was for some time involved with the Creators when OpAphid was the official ARG of the LG15 series.
Mission
We need your comments. Look at the series we already have, look at the series that exist that we don't have yet, and rate them using the criteria above. Try to determine whether a series is notable enough to be listed, and, if yes, which tier it belongs to. Remember to post your reasoning ;)
Free for all comment space
Add your comments and opinions below this line.
Starting Fresh, Perhaps
So I've been reading this section and not commenting, just observing. After lurking for a while on, not only this convo, but chat, LG15 Today, Inside LG15, the comment boards, and the forums, I've decided to post what I feel may be closest to the opinion of the majority. Every series I'm listing has had thought behind it, so if there are ones you don't agree with, I'm happy to lay out my reasons (as long as too many people don't do this, hehe, I'll get swamped!)
Anywho, the listings:
Tier 1: The 707 clique, Aaronbeast, Breeiswaiting, Brucker, Bubbleteagirl, Cassieresurrection, The Deacons, EWLPRI, Fourthface, GuillotineCalamity, Iris2009, Maccaboy17, Marbella, Mission Anchor Cove, MsBlackBetty, N3ural N3t, OpScorn, ProjectStatic, Kelseygirl15, Lonelydude15, RefusEtoBeliEveLies, Sarahsnotebook, StormFaction, Scdgoofy, TheLadyLazarus, TWJaniak, UtNbErS tutlaEN, majority of the New Girls
Tier 2: ApotheosisAZ, Cassie UGC (consisting of, CIW and itscassie, but also breeiswaiting, cassieresurrection, frankiswaking, frankiswaiting@gmail.com cassieisevil, cassieiswatching222, cassieseesall, etc) Deemontreal, Dreams from the Breeniverse, MessyNessy89, The Homeschoolers Aggregate, Xeniph, The Coalition (consisting of Facility J, Will-O-Wisp, Wordfiles, ZorinXL), Zoey fanfic(??, lol am I biased here?) (including zoeyiswatching and opzoeyd)
Tier 3: Acrowleyorder, Cassieiswatching, Immant, LonesomeOctober, LordGreystoke422, Paulmark18
Tier 4: lonelygirl362436, The Flock (The Flock being Tier 4 with the condition that they keep it up to date themselves, the details of this can be hashed out later), Itscassie, LonelyJew15
Tier 5: Maddison Atkins, OpAphid, Redearth88
Let me know your thoughts! --Zoey 16:46, 26 February 2008 (CST)
- I think they are more fair. Definitely a better starting point for discussion. I have no objections.--Immortal1 17:05, 26 February 2008 (CST)
- No objections, Zoey. Let's do it!! --Virginian9000 28:54, 26 February 2008 (EST)
- I concur. Although, some of the Tier 3 listings are currently being upkept as Tier 2s... Are they going to be expanded more? I still maintain my opinion that only Tier 5 videos should have transcripts, but since I seem to be the voice of the minority, I suppose we can expand it to two. (We do need to set a firm line, though.)
- I will also say that anything Tier 3 or above should get some actual content regarding the SERIES, and not solely the videos. I think if we can't get that together, it should bump it down a bit in the rankings.
- Also, I think I should add, as I explained in the chat (and apparently neglected to do so above) my earlier listing was not meant to be definitive in any way, and was simply thrown together based on what little I knew of the series, and what content was available. I just wanted to put them out there for discussion.
- Once the tiers get hashed out, we should archive the discussion and go on to discussions on how exactly to change each series page for the better. They all could stand some serious work. - Shiori 18:00, 26 February 2008 (CST)
- When you say "consisting of...", does that mean we'll unify all sub-series on one page? i.e., have only one Cassie UGC page then, not separate *cassie* pages?
- Have you checked whether any series has something special that'd bump them up, being featured in the Community Appreciation Week or something, for example?
- Will we make The Flock Deal a general offer?
- I think Zoey's proposal is proably the fairest one I've seen so far. As someone who spends a lot of their time on the fanfic area of the LGPedia, and as a fan of many of the UGC series out there. I will say this: I think every three months or so there should be a place where people can state their case for why something should change tiers or not. --FH14 27 February 2008 (EST)
- No objections on my end, Zoey. :) And I really like that idea, FH14 -- who's to say every show is going to be the same forevermore?? -- --Pheon 11:55, 27 February 2008 (CST)
Redesign Discussion
This is independent of any discussion regarding tier placement for now, although once we agree on tiers, further discussion should go on here.
- Moved to the main page.
