Talk:YourMomisSmarmy

Deletion

I think a mention in the fanfic page is more than sufficient, so I support the deletion. OwenIsCool 16:52, 29 January 2007 (CST)

Seconded. 153.104.138.125 16:58, 29 January 2007 (CST)

I totally am against this. If we delete this I support the deletion of every single user page. Instead of deleting stuff why not spend some time and investigate the video. Do a transcript. Decode the backmasking at the end of the video. See what's written on the walls. Make a guide to the Don't F-with Lonely girl dance. Post their other LG15 related video on the page. I want to SUPPORT fan interaction not DELETE it. This crap BURNS my ass. Fan fic was promised support by the LG15 site by the creators..well where the hell is it? LGPedia is an OPPORTUNITY to support things. Just because YOU don't like it..does not mean others don't. I think EVERY video maker with an original video deserves an LGpedia page. SURE its not an easy task..but we can TRY. Instead of deletion..Sorry if it sullies your PURITY with superflous articles. --LordGreystoke422 17:36, 29 January 2007 (CST)

Those are all great suggestions, but unfortunately, YourMomisSmarmy lacks the kind of following needed to put all of that together. You don't need to be so inflammatory when you disagree with deletion nominations. How would you like it if I said that if you don't support the deletion then you have to a comprehensive article for every single person that ever posted an LG15-related video online? Neither extreme makes any sense. Everyone's welcome to create fanfiction, but we're by no means obligated to slave away transcribing all the minutae of each one of them. By the way, a User page is for people who actually participate in the LGPedia, comment boards, forums.. they're like User profiles, not articles. You don't delete people's profiles on the forum if they don't post constantly, right? That's why the comparison is null. OwenIsCool 17:46, 29 January 2007 (CST)

In response to the absurd, but apparently straightfaced question about where the hell is the fanfic on the LGPedia, here's a starting point: Blogspot Frank, Cassieiswatching, Cassieiswatching (Clue 1), Cassieiswatching (Clue 2), Cassieiswatching (Clue 23), Cassieiswatching clues , Frankiswaking, Revelation 1, Revelation 3, This Is My Story Now, When I Get To The Bottom Where I Stop, Fourthface, Frankiswaiting@gmail.com, Frankiswaking, GuillotineCalamity, Immant, Iris2009, Itscassie, Itscassie's Chat, ApotheosisAZ, VoyBoy, LonesomeOctober, LordGreystoke422, "LordGreystoke422/Gabriel", LordGreystoke422/Post 218, LordGreystoke422/Post 273, LordGreystoke422/ZombZ, Nikki Bower, Other fanfic ,Paulmark18, RefusEtoBeliEveLies, The Deacons (commenter), The Homeschoolers Aggregate, TheLadyLazarus ,UtNbErS tutlaEN, Deemontreal, Terryfic, Orange Slurpee, Flee, Greetings from the Order., Order Announcement: New Policy to Combat Misinformation, See you at the ceremony..., Marbella, Seeing the Big Picture, The Doctor is in..., The Order MAQs (Most Asked Questions), The Shut Eye, We do not wish to make enemies, only friends., Depression, Escape Attempt (Part I), Escape Attempt (Part II), Got a ?, I found alot of weird stuff., Investigating, Jonas is your best option., Lab Rat, Me and Daniel went swimming..., My little secret..., Nightmare, Pick up the phone!, Sneaking out, Stolen Goods, Um, hi bree., Yearbook, You didnt see a thing., You're not ready., Lonelygirl15 Cthulhu Interview, An Ode to Bree's Dad, Be Careful Daniel!, Introducing... Paul and Andrea, Mythical Creature Contest, Tales from the Minibar, Assignment 1--October 9, 2006, Assignment 2-- October 12, 2006, Assignment 3--October 18, 2006, Assignment 4- October 19, 2006, Assignment 5- October 25, 2006, Assignment 6- October 25, 2006 -- not to mention all the Nikki Bower stuff and OpAphid stuff that started as fan fiction.

YourMomIsSmarmy deleted their other video from YouTube. The video in question is three months old, was watched 2,000 times, and actually has more to do with a spin-off of a spin-off than lonelygirl15. And we didn't even propose deleting YourMomIsSmarmy from the LGPedia!! We proposed moving it to the Other fanfic page -- where more people will see it anyways! -- and deleting this individual page. I merely proposed a reorganization!!--JayHenry 18:11, 29 January 2007 (CST)

Do you guys know what happened to Immant? He got upset at the lack of Fan vid support and took a break. Let me say he said you guys had been very kind to him here... but he still felt the promise from the creators never appeared. Jay..please get my absurd assertions right..I never said there wasnt fanfic in the pedia...I said" Fan fic was promised support by the LG15 site by the creators..well where the hell is it? LGPedia is an OPPORTUNITY to support things." Can we say that like Immant..its a peeve of mine. OIC actually..the user page issue IS the same because a Lot(well at least some) of the user pages for people from the chat were written and created by other people. Plus..now with the chat DEAD..and StarLady having banned everyone last week from the LG15 userplane chat room that she knew from before..the chat pages are pretty worthless. Anyway..nothing will probably come of it..but..I am putting my..whatever where my mouth is.. I am going to make a recruitment video for the LGpedia. Hopefully it's not a nightmare..but..I've got a concept running that fits with my recent vids and we will have to see how it works out. I figure we might get a dozen ding dongs in the immediate time frame and if we can get 2 or 3 good regular editors from the pedia..and a few part timers....we've got something. Only time will tell..if you plan my death...I'd prefer a good sword..or a large caliber round.. --LordGreystoke422 18:50, 29 January 2007 (CST)

LordGreystoke, my apologies. I mistook your frustration with the whole site as specific to the LGPedia. I understand your concern and Immant's concern about fan videos. I personally thought fan videos were going to be a more integral part of the site too (and, who knows, maybe it's still in the works), and I certainly understand why you, Immant and I'm sure others, are frustrated. I think I speak for all of us when I say we're excited to support fan-fiction and fan-interaction here at the wiki, but that doesn't mean every theory and every response video. And don't worry -- although we might occasionally disagree about the merit of a page -- nobody is planning your death!--JayHenry 23:33, 29 January 2007 (CST)

JayHenry I must say...once again..you are mistaken..there are many planning my death..or at least hoping for it..even if you aren't one of them. Also..let's see if I can manage to draw in some recruits. Ok..Fantasy time..could you imagine if we got 5 serious committed contributors along with some part timers. Ok..Reality time..get you rollback button ready! Here comes my LGpedia recruitment video...well as soon as I make it..I felt a need for the bookshelf... It is a Pedia after all.--LordGreystoke422 23:44, 29 January 2007 (CST)

OK so this has been nominated for deletion for quite some time. Are we going to move this back to fanfic page or what? Personally I think if someone only made one fanfic video and it's not even on-line anymore, it really had no effect on the Breeniverse and doesn't really need it's own page. I'd certainly support a link to the video on the Other Fanfic page, however if the video is deleted from youtube now I don't see the point because it's not possible... 153.104.64.154 11:33, 20 February 2007 (CST)

This has been up in the air for a while, but I agree it should go the way of merging with Other fanfic, which by the way, is where it used to be mentioned. OwenIsCool 15:23, 20 February 2007 (CST)